5-Year-Old ‘Rent’ Rule: One Mom’s Simple Money Lesson
A creative mom's method of deducting 'rent' from her 5-year-old's allowance sparks debate on early financial lessons.
This Mom Charges Her 5-Year-Old “Rent” — and the Internet Is Freaking Out
Teaching children about money management from a young age is crucial for building lifelong financial habits. Many financial experts recommend starting these conversations early to prepare kids for real-world responsibilities like paying bills. One mother’s unique approach to this—charging her 5-year-old daughter “rent” from her weekly allowance—has ignited a firestorm of debate online.
Why Start Teaching Kids About Money Early?
Financial literacy isn’t just for adults; introducing basic concepts to children helps them understand the value of money, the importance of saving, and the reality of expenses. According to a survey by The Penny Hoarder, less than 15% of Americans discussed family finances growing up, and over one-third never talked about personal finance at all. Those who missed these discussions often lack financial goals, have less savings, and struggle with budgeting.
Parents play a pivotal role in bridging this gap. By involving kids in age-appropriate money talks, families can foster responsibility and independence. This is especially important as children transition to adulthood, where bills like rent and utilities become unavoidable realities.
The Mom’s “Rent” System Explained
Essence Evans, a mother from an unspecified location, shared her method on Facebook, detailing how she handles her 5-year-old daughter’s $7 weekly allowance. Out of this amount, she deducts $5—$1 each for rent, water, electricity, cable, and food—leaving the child with $2 to spend or save freely.
This isn’t about collecting actual payments for household bills, as the small sum wouldn’t cover real costs. Instead, Evans secretly sets the deducted money aside in an account her daughter can access at 18. The goal is to simulate adult budgeting, showing how “most people spend most of their paycheck on bills.” Evans aims to teach her child early that necessities come first, preventing the shock of real bills in adulthood.
| Allowance Breakdown | Amount | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Total Weekly Allowance | $7 | Given to child |
| Rent | $1 | Simulate housing costs |
| Water | $1 | Utility bill lesson |
| Electricity | $1 | Utility bill lesson |
| Cable | $1 | Utility/entertainment cost |
| Food | $1 | Groceries/household needs |
| Remaining for Child | $2 | Spend/save freely |
This structured breakdown mirrors real-life budgeting rules like the 50/30/20 method, where 50% goes to needs (similar to Evans’ deductions), 30% to wants, and 20% to savings. For parents, adapting such systems for kids simplifies teaching without overwhelming them.
Positive Reactions: A Smart Financial Lesson
Many praise Evans’ approach as innovative and practical. Supporters argue it provides hands-on experience in allocating money for necessities versus discretionary spending. One key benefit is that allowance becomes a privilege tied to learning, not an entitlement. Parents could simply give less allowance and save separately, but this method embeds the budgeting lesson directly.
- Builds budgeting skills early: Kids learn to prioritize bills before fun spending.
- Sets money aside for future: The deducted funds grow into a nest egg, combining education with savings.
- Prepares for adulthood: Avoids the common pitfall where young adults face bills without prior knowledge.
Financial planners echo this, recommending tools like piggy banks or play money to make learning engaging. Sharing family goals, like saving for college, further reinforces the process.
Criticisms and Controversies
Not everyone agrees. Evans’ post exploded with over 42,000 comments, 307,000 shares, and 219,000 likes/reactions. Critics argue 5 years old is too young for bill-paying concepts, calling it “too much pressure” that could cause anxiety. Some say it robs kids of childhood innocence, insisting “let kids be kids.” Others criticize it for fostering a “slave to bills” mindset or omitting expenses like gas or insurance.
- Age-appropriateness concerns: Is a kindergartener ready for adult financial stress?
- Missing real-life nuances: Not all bills are covered, potentially giving incomplete picture.
- Potential for resentment: Could make money feel punitive rather than empowering.
Media outlets like Scary Mommy, Working Mother, and Romper amplified the debate, highlighting divided parental opinions.
Alternative Ways Parents Teach Kids About Money
Evans isn’t alone in creative methods. Other parents use contracts, real-world challenges, or structured jars to impart lessons.
- Allowance Contracts: One dad drafts detailed agreements outlining chores for pay, with annual renegotiations, teaching negotiation and accountability.
- Three-Jar System: Divide earnings into spend, save, and give jars. Popular for youth, paired with family budgeting meetings using calculators.
- Survival Challenges: A businessman sent his teen out with minimal money and no connections for a month to emphasize hard work.
- No Inheritance Policy: Gordon Ramsay vows not to leave his fortune to his kids, pushing self-reliance.
Certified financial planners suggest five easy steps: Use piggy banks for saving excitement; play money for goals like movie nights; share shopping experiences; discuss family savings goals; and involve kids in parental goals like vacations. Apps like Greenlight or GoHenry help older kids track allowances digitally.
Expert Tips for Financial Literacy at Every Age
The Penny Hoarder’s survey of 1,500 people underscores the need for early education: One-third learned no basic finance concepts growing up. Here’s how to tailor lessons:
| Age Group | Key Lessons | Tools/Activities |
|---|---|---|
| 3-5 Years | Needs vs. Wants, Basic Saving | Piggy banks, Allowance deductions like Evans |
| 6-10 Years | Budgeting, Goal-Setting | Three jars, Play money goals |
| 11-15 Years | Compound Interest, Debt | Savings accounts, Budget apps, Family meetings |
| 16+ Years | Real Budgets, Jobs | Part-time work, 50/30/20 rule |
Discuss money like adults: Share attitudes openly. Involve kids in grocery shopping or coupon clipping to show real costs. For families, the 50/30/20 budget adapts well—50% needs, 30% wants, 20% savings/debt—teaching proportionality.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Is 5 years old too young to learn about bills like rent?
A: Opinions vary, but experts say age-appropriate intros build habits without stress. Evans’ method uses small amounts playfully.
Q: What if my child resists the ‘rent’ deduction?
A: Frame it as a game or family rule. Use visual jars to show savings growth, turning it positive.
Q: How much allowance is right for kids?
A: Base it on age (e.g., $1 per year) or chores. Tie to responsibilities for value lesson.
Q: Are there risks to early financial talks?
A: Minimal if positive. Avoid pressure; focus on empowerment to prevent anxiety.
Q: What’s the best way to save deducted allowance?
A: High-yield savings or 529 plans. Inform kids of future access for motivation.
Q: How does 50/30/20 apply to teaching kids?
A: Simplify: Majority for needs, some for fun, rest saved. Great for older children.
Every family tailors these lessons differently, but consistency matters. Whether through ‘rent,’ jars, or contracts, the aim is equipped kids for financial independence.
References
- This Mom Charges Her 5-Year-Old “Rent” – The Penny Hoarder — The Penny Hoarder. 2019 (approx., based on post date). https://www.thepennyhoarder.com/save-money/teaching-kids-about-money-rent/
- Financial Literacy For Kids in 5 Easy Steps – YouTube — The Penny Hoarder. 2019-04-23. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDKkT8C_z7c
- 50/30/20 Budget: A Simple Guide to Financial Freedom for Parents — Mostt.co. Recent (post-2023). https://mostt.co/blog/50-30-20-budget-a-simple-guide-to-financial-freedom-for-parents
- Family Budgeting Strategy for Youth – The Penny Hoarder Community — The Penny Hoarder Community. Recent forum post. https://community.thepennyhoarder.com/t/family-budgeting-strategy-for-youth/982
- 10 Money Lessons Every Parent Should Teach Their Kids — The Penny Hoarder. Recent survey-based. https://www.thepennyhoarder.com/budgeting/budgeting-for-kids/
Similar Articles
Read full bio of Sneha Tete
