Medi-Share Review: Legitimate Health Plan With Limited Coverage
Is Medi-Share right for you? Explore its costs, coverage, and limitations in this comprehensive review.
If you’re exploring healthcare options beyond traditional insurance, you’ve likely encountered Medi-Share. This faith-based health sharing ministry promises to help members manage medical costs through a community-supported model. But does it live up to its promises? Our comprehensive review examines how Medi-Share works, what it costs, what it covers, and most importantly, whether it’s the right choice for your family’s healthcare needs.
What Is Medi-Share?
Medi-Share is a health sharing ministry that operates on a fundamentally different principle than traditional health insurance. Instead of paying premiums to an insurance company that pools risk across millions of members, Medi-Share members contribute monthly shares that go directly toward paying other members’ eligible medical bills. This creates a community-based approach to healthcare cost management grounded in shared values and mutual support.
The program operates under the belief that members should support one another’s healthcare burdens, particularly unexpected medical expenses. While the concept appeals to many people seeking alternatives to conventional insurance, it’s essential to understand how Medi-Share differs fundamentally from regulated health insurance plans, as these differences significantly impact coverage guarantees and member protections.
How Much Does Medi-Share Cost?
Initial Enrollment Fees
Before you can start using Medi-Share, you’ll need to cover several upfront costs:
- Application fee: $50
- Initial membership fee: $120 (paid with your first monthly share)
- Sharing account setup fee: $2
Monthly Share Amounts
Your monthly share payment works similarly to a health insurance premium, ensuring your eligibility for assistance when you need it. Medi-Share structures its pricing system to resemble choosing a health insurance deductible paired with a monthly premium, giving members flexibility in selecting their coverage level based on their budget and healthcare needs.
The monthly shares vary based on your age, family size, and selected coverage tier. Younger, healthier members typically pay less than older members or those with certain health conditions. This tiered approach allows members to customize their participation level according to their financial situation and healthcare expectations.
Health Partnership Program Additional Costs
If you have certain pre-existing health conditions such as heart disease, high cholesterol, or diabetes, you’ll be automatically enrolled in Medi-Share’s mandatory Health Partnership Program. This program pairs you with a health coach and costs an additional $99 per month beyond your regular share payment. While this adds to your monthly expenses, the program aims to help members manage chronic conditions more effectively through preventative care coaching and lifestyle support.
How Does Medi-Share Work?
Understanding the mechanics of how Medi-Share operates is crucial for determining whether this model aligns with your healthcare needs and financial situation.
The Sharing Model
As a Medi-Share member, your monthly share contribution enters a collective pool. When other members who have met their Annual Household Portion (AHP) need financial assistance with medical bills, those shares from other members are used to help cover eligible expenses. This creates a circular system where your contributions may directly help fellow community members, and conversely, other members’ contributions support your medical costs when you need them.
The Annual Household Portion (AHP)
Medi-Share uses the Annual Household Portion system, which functions similarly to a deductible but with important differences. Notably, if you apply as a family, you’ll have a single Annual Household Portion to meet across all family members, unlike typical insurance plans that often have per-person deductibles. This means your family’s combined out-of-pocket expenses count toward a single threshold, potentially making it easier to reach cost-sharing eligibility as a unit.
Point-of-Service Costs
When you receive medical care at a Medi-Share provider, you’ll encounter the following costs at the point of service:
- Doctor visits: $35
- Hospitalizations: $35
- Emergency room visits: $200
These fixed costs remain consistent across all members regardless of the actual service provided, offering predictability in out-of-pocket expenses for common medical encounters.
Do You Need to Be Religious to Use Medi-Share?
Medi-Share explicitly embraces Christian values and lifestyle principles as core to its membership. According to the program’s guidelines, “Medi-Share members and their dollars do not pay for abortions, drug addictions, or any other unbiblical lifestyles.” This means the program reserves the right to deny coverage for certain medical treatments and conditions based on interpretations of Christian doctrine.
While Medi-Share doesn’t technically require members to be religious to join, the program’s values-based approach means that member contributions won’t fund treatments or services the organization deems inconsistent with Christian principles. This philosophical foundation significantly impacts coverage decisions and makes Medi-Share most suitable for individuals and families whose personal health values align with these faith-based principles.
What Does Medi-Share Cover?
Covered Services
Medi-Share covers a variety of medical services, though coverage eligibility ultimately remains subject to Christian Care Ministry’s discretion. Eligible medical expenses that apply toward your AHP include:
- Annual physical examinations
- Telemedicine visits (no cost)
- Prescription drugs (eligible for cost-sharing up to six months for the lifetime of the member)
- Maternity and adoption expenses
- COVID-19 testing and treatment
- Emergency and urgent care services
- Hospitalizations and surgical procedures
- Diagnostic testing (when medically necessary for acute conditions)
Coverage Exclusions and Limitations
Medi-Share’s coverage limitations are extensive and represent significant gaps compared to traditional health insurance. Understanding these exclusions is critical before enrolling:
Mental and Behavioral Health: Behavioral and mental health care are entirely ineligible for coverage. This includes psychiatric care, psychological treatment, counseling, and care for learning deficiencies or behavioral problems such as ADD or autism. For members struggling with mental health challenges, this represents a substantial coverage gap.
Routine Preventative Screenings: Here’s a major catch: routine health screenings aren’t eligible for cost-sharing. If your doctor recommends getting a colonoscopy because you’ve reached a certain age or based on family history, you cannot submit the test for Medi-Share payment. However, if you have symptoms warranting the same test, the program might grant payment. This distinction between preventative and symptomatic testing creates confusion and potentially discourages beneficial preventative care.
Dental and Vision Care: Dental and vision services fall outside coverage, though Medi-Share does advertise discounts with select dental and vision providers. Members must cover these expenses independently or through supplemental discount plans.
Prescription Drug Limitations: While some prescription drugs qualify for cost-sharing, this benefit is strictly limited to six months total for a member’s lifetime. After exhausting this benefit, members must pay for medications entirely out-of-pocket.
What if You Have an Ongoing Health Condition?
Medi-Share explicitly acknowledges that its primary purpose is helping members manage unexpected medical burdens rather than providing comprehensive coverage for chronic illness. The program states: “The primary purpose of Medi-Share is to help share members’ burdens. Burdens are those unexpected medical bills you are unable to plan for (i.e., broken bones, cancer, etc). Low monthly share amounts enable you to budget for your family’s routine care, which can be planned.”
This fundamental philosophy means that anyone suffering from chronic health issues is probably better served by exploring Affordable Care Act health insurance programs. Members with conditions requiring ongoing medication, regular specialist visits, or frequent medical management will likely find Medi-Share inadequate and financially stressful. The program’s structure works best for healthy individuals who rarely need medical care and can afford to cover routine healthcare expenses independently.
So, Is Medi-Share Legit?
Legitimacy Assessment
Medi-Share is legitimate in the sense that it’s a real organization with a strong membership base, transparent operations, and a track record of functioning as described. The program has successfully operated for years, maintaining member communities and processing medical expense sharing. However, legitimacy doesn’t equate to being the best healthcare choice for everyone.
Key Considerations
| Factor | Assessment |
|---|---|
| Organization Status | Legitimate health sharing ministry with established operations |
| Cost-Effectiveness | Likely not the most affordable option for most people |
| Regulatory Oversight | Not subject to ACA regulations like traditional insurance |
| Coverage Guarantees | No guaranteed coverage; discretionary by Christian Care Ministry |
| Ideal Candidates | Healthy individuals with robust savings and aligned values |
Important Regulatory Differences
A critical distinction between Medi-Share and traditional health insurance involves regulatory oversight. Medi-Share and similar cost-sharing programs aren’t subject to regulation like ACA-compliant health insurance plans. While a traditional health insurance benefits booklet clearly outlines what’s covered and guarantees coverage up to specific amounts or percentages, Medi-Share participants may struggle to determine ahead of time which medical bills will be paid by the program. This uncertainty represents a significant disadvantage compared to regulated insurance products.
Ideal Candidate Profile
The ideal candidate for Medi-Share possesses specific characteristics:
- Excellent overall health status
- Robust personal savings account
- Ability to pay out-of-pocket for routine medical care
- Comfort with discretionary coverage decisions
- Alignment with Christian values and lifestyle principles
- No chronic health conditions requiring ongoing medication or specialist care
- Minimal need for mental health services
Is Medi-Share Right for You?
While Medi-Share probably isn’t the best financial choice for most people, it does serve as a viable option for specific populations. Those without access to job-sponsored health insurance plans or who find individual ACA coverage options prohibitively expensive may find Medi-Share’s lower monthly shares appealing. Additionally, individuals whose healthcare values align with the program’s faith-based principles and who maintain excellent health may benefit from this alternative.
However, before committing to Medi-Share, carefully evaluate your personal healthcare needs, financial situation, and values alignment. Consider whether the coverage exclusions—particularly the gaps in mental health services and routine preventative screenings—could leave you financially vulnerable.
Frequently Asked Questions About Medi-Share
Q: What is the difference between Medi-Share and traditional health insurance?
A: Medi-Share is a health sharing ministry where members contribute shares that fund other members’ medical bills, while traditional insurance is a regulated contract where an insurance company pools premiums and guarantees certain coverage levels. Traditional insurance is subject to ACA regulations; Medi-Share is not.
Q: Can I use Medi-Share if I have a pre-existing condition?
A: While you can apply with a pre-existing condition, certain conditions like heart disease, diabetes, or high cholesterol require enrollment in the additional Health Partnership Program ($99/month). Comprehensive chronic disease management is better suited to traditional insurance.
Q: Are mental health services covered by Medi-Share?
A: No. Behavioral and mental health care, including psychiatric treatment, counseling, and care for learning disabilities, are completely ineligible for coverage under Medi-Share.
Q: What happens if my medical bills exceed my AHP?
A: Once you’ve met your Annual Household Portion, Medi-Share begins sharing eligible medical expenses with other members’ contributions. However, there’s no guarantee of full coverage, as Medi-Share maintains discretionary authority over what qualifies for sharing.
Q: Do preventative care visits count toward my AHP?
A: Annual physicals are covered, and telemedicine visits cost nothing. However, routine preventative screenings like colonoscopies aren’t eligible for cost-sharing unless you have symptoms warranting the test.
Q: How long does it take for Medi-Share to process medical bills?
A: Processing times vary, but Medi-Share typically works directly with providers. Contact Medi-Share directly for specific information about processing timelines for your particular situation.
Q: What are the family versus individual plan differences?
A: Family plans have a single Annual Household Portion shared among all family members, unlike some insurance plans with per-person deductibles. This can make reaching cost-sharing eligibility faster for families.
Making Your Healthcare Decision
Choosing a healthcare plan is deeply personal and requires careful consideration of your specific circumstances. Medi-Share offers a legitimate alternative to traditional insurance for specific populations, particularly healthy individuals with emergency funds and aligned values. However, its extensive coverage limitations, lack of regulatory oversight, and discretionary coverage decisions make it unsuitable for most people, especially those with chronic conditions or significant mental health needs.
Before enrolling in Medi-Share, compare it thoroughly against ACA marketplace plans available in your area. Calculate potential out-of-pocket costs for your family’s anticipated healthcare needs, and carefully review the coverage exclusions. Only proceed with Medi-Share if its limitations align with your healthcare needs and financial capacity.
References
- Medi-Share Review: Legitimate Health Plan With Limited Coverage — The Penny Hoarder Staff. 2022-05-13. https://www.thepennyhoarder.com/save-money/medishare-reviews/
- How to Avoid Medicare Mistakes That Could Cost You Thousands — The Penny Hoarder. https://www.thepennyhoarder.com/retirement/medicare-mistakes/
- Are Health Sharing Plans a Good Way to Save Money on Health Care? — The Penny Hoarder. https://www.thepennyhoarder.com/insurance/health-sharing-plans/
Similar Articles
Read full bio of Sneha Tete
